Ready to Explore New Possibilities?


Claims Information

Welch Insurance Agency is available during regular business hours Monday through Friday, 9 to 5. The number to reach us is 239.768.5333. In the event of an after hours emergency, please call your carrier’s toll-free number below.

Please contact Welch Insurance Agency, LLC. at your convenience for an initial consultation. We’ll work with you one on one to determine a roadmap to success. We look forward to working with you soon.

​Call Today: 239.768.5333

 Olympus Insurance (HOMEOWNERS)  1.866.281.2242  or

 Olympus Insurance (FLOOD) 1.866.931.1306

 Progressive 1.800.776.4737  or

 Centauri Insurance  1.866.215.7574 (HOMEOWNERS) 1.866.789.4228

1.877.254.6819 (FLOOD) 

Travelers 1.800.252.4633  or

 United Property and Casualty (HOMEOWNERS) 1.888.256.3378  or

 United Property and Casualty (FLOOD) 1.800.759.8656 or

 Universal Property and Casualty 1.800.425.9113 or

Elements Property Insurance Co (Avatar)  1.877.233.3237  or

 Homeowners Choice 1.866.324.3138  or

 Safe Point Insurance 1.855.CLAIM15  or

American Strategic Insurance (ASI)/Ark Royal Insurance  1.866.274.8765 or

 American Traditions/Modern USA    1.866.270.8430 or

 Citizens  1.866.411.2742  or

 Hagerty Classic Car Insurance 1.888.220.9565 or

​Heritage Insurance 1.855.415.7120 or